Email marketing for recruitment agencies
A free email brief for recruitment agencies, built from real salary guides, market letters and sector digests that other search firms sent. Turn the offers your desk has seen into a note hiring managers reply to.
Recruitment agenciesEmail marketingBrief
Free brief · no sign-up
A salary note to hiring managers, built from the offers your own desk handled
An email brief for a small recruitment agency with a list of hiring managers it has worked with or met, sent twice a year from one consultant's desk.
- Channel
- Email marketing
- Format
- Salary note
- Audience
- Hiring managers in one sector, never the candidate list
- Measured by
- Tracked link, with replies and new roles per send
Brief outline
6 sections
-
01
Subject and preheader
Name the roles and the period: "What finance managers accepted, January to June". A hiring manager opens a number about their own team, not "our latest newsletter". Keep it short enough to read whole on a phone.
-
02
Where the numbers come from
Say it in one line: how many offers and placements, which roles, which region, which months. Omna Search, a team of five, builds its annual guide from benchmarks its readers send in. Your desk's own offers are a source no salary survey can copy, so say so.
-
03
Three numbers and one surprise
A band per level, the gap between what candidates asked for and what they took, and one thing that swung offers that was not pay. Steadman Hub found 3 in 5 HubSpot professionals ranked flexible working first after career development. One surprise from your desk beats ten rows from a table.
-
04
What it means if you are hiring this quarter
One practical move for a manager with an open role, set against the wider market in a line (in the UK, the latest KPMG and REC Report on Jobs). Advice, not a pitch for your services.
-
05
One way to reply
Offer to benchmark one live role against your numbers, by replying to the consultant who wrote it. No vacancy list and no candidate profiles in this email; those are other emails, with other rules.
-
06
Sign-off and the next note
Signed by the consultant whose desk the numbers came from, with a direct line, and the month the next note will arrive. Link to a copy on your website too, since some company email filters block tracked links.
What it read
20 sources
Business context
How agencies sell to hiring managers and work with candidates, fees and temp billings, the hiring calendar, the rules on job adverts and email, and the words the trade uses.
Recruitment agency industry profile
Research
7 salary, market, sector and launch emails from six search and recruitment firms in the US and UK, plus 13 agencies whose marketing is documented in case studies, trade blogs and their own newsletters.
Playbook know-how
Mole Marketer's email marketing skill, on how strong emails are planned, written and measured.
Email marketing skill
On this page
The short version
- An agency has two lists that want different things: hiring managers who pay, and candidates who come back when they are ready to move. Write to them separately.
- Your most valuable email material is the offers your own desk has seen. Nobody else has those numbers.
- Send hiring managers a salary note twice a year: where the numbers come from, three of them, one surprise, one way to reply.
- Keep vacancies and candidate profiles out of it. A jobs email is an advert, with rules of its own.
- Copy the brief above for free. Take it into your email tool or CRM, or hand it to the consultant whose desk it draws on.
The emails an agency has to send, about roles and candidates, get sent. What gets lost is the email nobody has to send. Clients are hard to win in the gaps between vacancies: in Bullhorn's 2026 survey of recruitment industry professionals, hiring freezes and budget constraints were the biggest obstacles to winning new business, with competition from other firms second. When a role does open, Reed's marketing director says, "a percentage of leads will send their requirements to a few recruitment companies, so being first to get back to them is key." An agency that wrote something useful in the quiet months is the one a hiring manager thinks of in the busy ones.
What recruitment agencies actually send
Four emails from search firms, each written for a different reader. Each card opens the email as it was sent and quotes the line that did the work.
Omna Search · United States
Omna Search: Compensation Benchmarks 2023
“Each year, we collect compensation benchmarks from you to compile into our annual comp guide.”
A five-person firm's yearly guide, built from readers' own data. Featured jobs follow, then one line for candidates and one for clients.
Morgan Taylor Executive Search · United States
Healthcare Staffing Industry Digest: Candidates Are Checking Out Your Recruiters
“Having trouble opening a link? Some enterprise email filters block Substack’s redirect links.”
A Friday briefing for healthcare staffing leaders. Deals, executive moves and staffing data, with every link mirrored on its website.
Beth the Recruiter · Northwest Arkansas
“We’re seeing more interviews start… but fewer offers close. That’s not a boom. That’s hesitation.”
A Monday letter from an executive recruiter. National figures, then local ones, then one section for people in work and one for people searching.
Growth by Design Talent
Navigating the Current Executive Search Market
“companies are increasingly using "pocket listings" for senior talent and HR roles.”
A monthly letter to its talent community on why more senior roles are being filled through private networks before they are posted, and what to do about it.
Who's doing it well
Who's doing it well
“Candidates are receiving the email, they’re opening it, and they’re clicking the button to apply. If they don’t do it on the first few messages, when they are ready to actively look again, we are the first firm they think of and they don’t want to talk to anyone else.”
- Open rate after the switch
- Over 30%
- Unsubscribe rate
- Below 1%
- Of placements from its own database
- Over 60%
Allen Recruitment's directors both came from IT backgrounds, "more specifically data", and the case shows it. The agency stopped sending one-off emails to candidates and moved to steady, planned contact from its own database. Brian Cunningham's reason was that "a new job may not be high on their priority list when we choose to email or call them." Unless you land them a job, the case study says, candidates "totally forget about you". "We didn't want them to forget about us," Cunningham says. The result, as Bullhorn tells it, is that most of its placements now come from people it already knew.
What the best ones do differently
They use what only their desk knows. Omna Search builds its compensation guide from figures its readers send in, and gives one overall reading before any table. Revoco's marketing manager, quoted by SourceFlow, says clients are "only receiving a couple a year" of these, and that its guides bring "a few huge leads" each year.
They write about the client's industry, not their own. Morgan Taylor's Friday digest covers hospital mergers, executive appointments and staffing data for healthcare staffing leaders. Its about page promises "No noise. No “recruitment hacks.”"
They say what they see on the ground. Beth the Recruiter gives the national jobs figures, then her own region's, then what recruiters are seeing in interviews and offers. The local line is the one a reader cannot get from the news.
They go back to people they placed. Signature Consultants set reminders before each contract ended and automated messages to consultants it had lost touch with. Its business application analyst, Mandy Franje, told Bullhorn, its software supplier: "We actually got a few placements just from reconnecting with people we had a relationship with."
Where recruitment emails go wrong
The jobs list as a newsletter. Ten roles and a "get in touch" is an advert, and in Great Britain regulation 27 says each one needs the hirer's authority and must say whether it is temporary or permanent. Send vacancies to candidates who asked for them, and give hiring managers something worth reading instead.
One email for everyone. A candidate wants to know where the roles are; a hiring manager wants to know what they cost. Lloyd Staffing began with one newsletter for senior leaders, then added four by specialty. Even a two-person desk can keep two lists.
The guide nobody hears about. A salary survey takes weeks to build and one afternoon to forget. Kris Holland, founder of Kitto Recruitment Marketing, warns that "The distribution is as important as the creation of the asset itself." The note in the brief is that distribution: three numbers in the inbox, the full guide one link away.
A year of emails, on the hiring calendar
Recruitment has two rushes, and they are not at the same time for both sides. LinkedIn's analysis of about 33 million paid job posts from 2016 to 2018 found January brings the most views and applications per job but the fewest live jobs, while October and November are the busiest two months for posting. Write to candidates as the year opens and to hiring managers before the autumn rush. In the UK, the National Living Wage moves temp rates every April.
spring
Mar
Salary note to hiring managers
When Omna Search sent its 2024 comp guide
Apr
Temp rates note
The National Living Wage rises on 1 April
summer
Aug to Sep
Second salary note
Before the autumn rush of new roles
autumn
Late Sep
Planning letter to clients
Hiring plans for next year are being drawn up
Oct to Nov
Roles round-up to candidates
The busiest two months for job posts
winter
Jan
Candidate market letter
The month with the most applications per job
Built from LinkedIn's posting data and UK dates. Elsewhere, swap in your own pay and data releases.
What to measure
Hiring managers read on work email, and many sit behind company filters. MailerLite's medians for recruitment and staffing show plenty of opens and fewer clicks than the average business. Count replies and roles that came from each note, against your own first three. For the candidate side, Allen Recruitment's measure was the share of placements that came from its own database.
| What to watch | Figure | How to read it |
|---|---|---|
| Open rate, recruitment and staffing | 45.26% | Inflated by Apple Mail marking emails as opened |
| Click rate | 1.68% | Below the all-industry 2.09%, so one link that matters beats many |
| Click-to-open rate | 5.29% | The share of openers who did something |
| Unsubscribe rate | 0.24% | A little above the all-industry 0.22%; watch it per list |
| Replies and new roles per send | Your first three notes | The number a salary note is for |
Source: MailerLite, email benchmarks by industry, median of campaigns sent December 2024 to November 2025
Pick your first email
If there is time for only one this month, let your desk decide.
- Start with a salary note if
- your desk has closed enough offers in one sector this half-year to say what a role really pays. It goes to hiring managers and asks for one reply.
- Start with a candidate market letter if
- January is coming. Candidates are looking hardest then, and a letter about what you are seeing gives them a reason to call you first.
- Start with a check-in to past candidates if
- your database is far bigger than your live roles. Ask what has changed for them since you last spoke, and redeploy before you advertise.
Make it a process, not one email
The first salary note gets written because a consultant had a quiet week. The second rarely does: billing comes first, the offer data sits in three people's heads, and the hiring manager list has not been cleaned since last year.
That is the gap Mole Marketer fills. Your marketing manager pitches the next piece of work, briefs it with your consultants' answers in it, puts a person and a send date on the marketing calendar, and shows through a tracked link which notes brought hiring managers to your site. Email is one of 53 marketing channels it can brief, so your salary guide, your LinkedIn posts and your client events can run the same way.
Frequently asked questions
Should we send one newsletter to clients and candidates?
Usually not. A hiring manager and a job seeker want different things from the same market. Lloyd Staffing began with one newsletter for senior leaders and added four more by specialty, and Reed started with email campaigns "to nurture our leadership audience". If the lists are small, Omna Search shows the honest compromise: one email, with a separate line at the foot for each.
Can we put live roles in a marketing email?
In Great Britain a jobs email is an advertisement. Regulation 27 of the Conduct Regulations asks it to carry the agency's full name and say whether each role is temporary or permanent, and not to advertise a position without "the authority of the hirer concerned". If you give a rate of pay, state the nature of the work, the location and the minimum experience or qualifications needed. That is a summary of the regulation, not legal advice.
Can we email everyone in our database?
Not automatically. In the UK, regulation 22 of PECR covers marketing email to individual subscribers, and its exemption speaks of details taken "in the course of the sale or negotiations for the sale" to that person. A candidate is not buying anything, so ask them. A hiring manager on a company address is usually a corporate subscriber, which regulation 22 does not cover, though data protection law still does. In the US the FTC's guide to CAN-SPAM wants a valid postal address in every message and unsubscribes dealt with inside 10 business days. Read this as a summary, not legal advice.
How often should a recruitment agency email its lists?
Candidates in a live process want more than most agencies give: in Bullhorn's candidate survey, 71% wanted to hear from their recruiter once a week or more and 56% said it happened. That is about updates on their process, not newsletters. For a list, pick a rhythm you can keep: Morgan Taylor writes every Friday, Growth by Design Talent once a month, and a salary note needs only two good sends a year.
Can Mole Marketer send the emails for us?
No. Mole Marketer plans and briefs the work and tracks what it brought in. You send from the email tool or CRM you already use, and your consultants write and approve every email.
Where to start
Use the brief at the top of this page. Pull the offers your desk handled since January, pick the three numbers a hiring manager in your sector would want, and write down the one that surprised you. Send it to the hiring managers you have worked with, and put the month of the next note in the calendar before this one goes out.